The Empty Spice Rack
My kitchen shelf holds five things: nước mắm (fish sauce), salt, sugar, chili and pepper. I only noticed how short that list was after looking into other people's kitchens. An Indian home keeps a masala tin with six or seven ground spices. An Indonesian cook pounds a dozen roots into bumbu before anything touches the pan. Next to them, our shelf looks unfinished.
Then I found the cinnamon. In the hills of Trà My, Quảng Nam, grows a cinnamon the Nguyễn court took as annual tribute. Emperor Minh Mạng had a cinnamon tree cast onto the Nghị Đỉnh, one of the Nine Dynastic Urns that still stand in the Huế citadel (VnExpress). Merchants carried Vietnamese cinnamon to Japan from the 17th to the 19th century (Okada 2012). The region grew a spice good enough to put on bronze, and its cooks barely put it in a pot. Pepper tells the same story. Vietnam supplies roughly 35–40% of the world's pepper and exported about 250,000 tonnes in 2024 (ITPC), yet at home pepper is a pinch scattered over soup at the end.
So Central Vietnamese cooks had spices within reach and chose not to stack them. This note records where the flavour went instead, with Huế at the centre.
Counting what's on the shelf
Someone did count spices across the world. In 1998 Jennifer Billing and Paul Sherman went through 4,578 meat recipes from 93 cookbooks in 36 countries and found that hotter countries use more spices, more often (Billing & Sherman 1998). Their idea was that spices kill bacteria, so hot climates select for spicy food. Vietnam is in their table, eighth hottest of the 36.
Their definition of "spice" changes the picture. They counted garlic, onion, chili and lemongrass as spices, and by that measure Vietnamese cooking is heavily spiced. They also left salt out on purpose, because "it is not a plant product." Anything fermented in salt fell outside the study. So did every jar of mắm. Their Vietnam data also came from two English-language national cookbooks, not from a Huế home kitchen.
That narrows my observation. It holds for one layer only, the dry ground spices. If I sort a Central kitchen into four drawers (dry spices, fresh aromatics, ferments, and things added at the table), only the first drawer is thin.
Even that drawer has a few things in it. Chili powder and pepper are there. Turmeric colours mì Quảng. Annatto seeds fried in oil turn bún bò Huế and mì Quảng orange-red, though annatto adds colour more than taste. And cinnamon and star anise do show up in a Huế meal, inside sa tế, the chili oil you spoon into bún bò at the table (Điện Máy Xanh). The dry spices moved out of the pot and into a jar on the table.
%% TODO: my own count. List everything in our kitchen by drawer (dry / fresh / ferments / table), then count the dry spices in 5–10 dishes we cook often. No published per-dish count exists for Central Vietnam vs India or Indonesia, so this number is mine. %%
Time in a jar
Nước mắm starts as anchovies and sea salt, about three parts fish to one part salt, layered in clay jars and left alone. At Nam Ô, the Đà Nẵng village whose craft became national intangible heritage in 2019, nothing else goes in, and the jars sit for 12 to 18 months (Nhân Dân). The salt holds off rot while the fish's own enzymes and salt-tolerant bacteria cut its protein into free amino acids (PMC7866574). The first drip from the bottom of the jar is nhĩ, the strongest grade, which can reach 40–45 °N (grams of nitrogen per litre) (Vietcetera).
The main amino acid that comes out is glutamate, the same molecule as MSG. A Thai fish sauce measures around 950 mg per 100 g, in the same range as soy sauce and aged parmesan (Umami Information Center). The long wait buys less than I assumed. In lab trials the nitrogen stops rising after about five months, so the extra year mostly changes the smell.
My first draft said fish sauce does everything in one bottle. The research says it has two gaps:
- No nucleotides. Fresh fish contains inosinate (IMP), which multiplies the umami effect of glutamate. Long fermentation breaks almost all of it down. Hạt nêm (seasoning powder) adds that partner back on purpose, as E627 and E631. Hạt nêm was built to cover what fish sauce lacks, so calling it a cheap copy of fish sauce misses what it does.
- No body. Stock gets its thickness from gelatin in the bones. Fish sauce has none, which is why bún bò Huế still simmers bones for hours. Fish sauce can stand in for the flavour of stock, but not its texture.
Heat doesn't ruin it either. A 2025 study boiled and stir-fried fish sauce and found its aroma compounds and free amino acids went up (Foods 2025), which fits the smell of peanuts or pork sizzling in a pan with nước mắm.
Nước mắm is only one jar on a long shelf. Lined up by how long each takes, the Huế and Quảng shelf runs from a few days to a year and a half:
- Mắm tôm chua, about a week. Whole shrimp are packed with sticky rice, galangal, garlic and chili, and turn sour fast (VnExpress). My guess is that the rice feeds lactic bacteria, but I found no source that says so. It is eaten with boiled pork belly wrapped in rice paper with khế (starfruit) and quả vả (fig).
- Mắm cá rò, one to two months. Small soft-boned fish from Thuận An are eaten whole. Sources disagree on whether roasted rice powder goes in (VnExpress).
- Mắm ruốc, around six months. Fishermen at the Thuận An river mouth call the tiny sea shrimp khuyết or tép biển (VnExpress). They belong to the genus Acetes, and nobody names the exact species. The shrimp are salted, ground and sun-dried three times over, then sealed for about six months (Nhân Dân). Researchers in Huế found Lactobacillus fermentum living in the 10–12% salt paste (HUAF 2019). Mắm ruốc is the base of bún bò Huế and cơm hến (rice with baby clams), and nobody dips anything in it.
- Mắm nêm, anywhere from three months to a year, depending on who you ask. It is usually anchovy, thinned at the table with minced pineapple, garlic and chili for bánh tráng cuốn thịt heo, pork rolled in rice paper (SGGP). The names mắm nêm and mắm cái overlap from village to village.
- Nước mắm Nam Ô, 12 to 18 months, and since 2024 one of only three fish sauces in Vietnam with a geographical indication (Báo Văn Hóa).
- Mắm dưa sits off the timeline. Dưa gang melon, papaya and cà pháo eggplant are brined, sun-dried, then mixed with steamed salted mackerel scad (cá nục) and chili (VnExpress). Here the mắm works as the seasoning for a vegetable pickle.
Each jar sits at a different point on the clock, ends up in a different form (liquid, paste, whole fish), and has its own job in the meal: cooking base, dip, or a side eaten with rice. A spice rack gets variety from many plants. This shelf gets it from time, salt and a handful of small sea creatures.
The garden and the table
The fresh drawer carries the aroma. Sả (lemongrass) is the main scent in bún bò. Củ nén is a small bulb-forming Allium that mì Quảng cannot do without. Sources can't agree on its species, though most say Allium schoenoprasum (Vi-Wikipedia). Ginger and fresh turmeric go in the pot. Huế also has four named chilis, ớt mọi, ớt hiểm, ớt chỉ thiên and ớt chìa vôi (VTC). Huế has the reputation of the spiciest food in the country, but I found no survey that measures it.
The herb plate adds a taste most spice lists don't have a word for. Shredded banana blossom (bắp chuối) goes with almost every Huế dish. A VnExpress writer says a plate without it loses its "sweet, astringent, soft" note (VnExpress). Green banana, starfruit and fig play the same role: astringency (chát) as a flavour of its own.
Sour comes from two places. At home ours is picked fresh: tamarind leaves (lá me) and lime. A trade-journal list of Central sour soups gives starfruit, pineapple, tomato, tai chua (dried garcinia) and pickled mustard greens, and no vinegar (Tạp chí Công Thương). The same list puts lá me under the South, so our tamarind leaves may be a family or local habit. Vinegar does appear in Huế, in vả trộn (fig salad), but rarely. It belongs in the ferment drawer, since it is rice wine that bacteria have turned into acetic acid, the same kind of process as mắm tôm chua and pickled greens.
The last layer is the table. A Huế meal always has muối tiêu ớt (salt, pepper and chili), nước mắm ớt tỏi (fish sauce with chili and garlic) or tương ớt (chili sauce) within reach (VTC). The cook leaves the dish a little short of finished, and each eater finishes it with chili, lime, herbs or another spoon of mắm. Much of the seasoning happens after the pot leaves the stove, which makes it hard to see from a list of ingredients.
Other kitchens have mắm too
Fermented fish and shrimp run through the whole region. Indonesia has terasi, Malaysia has belacan, Thailand has kapi and nam pla. So mắm alone can't explain an empty spice rack, because Indonesia has shrimp paste and bumbu.
A closer look at bumbu helped. Most of what gets pounded is fresh: shallot, garlic, galangal, candlenut and turmeric. Only a few dry spices go in (coriander, pepper, clove, nutmeg), and terasi is a pinch (Journal of Ethnic Foods). Both kitchens use fresh roots and fermented seafood. The difference I see (my reading, no source makes it) is in how they combine them. The Indonesian cook grinds everything into one paste before cooking. The Central cook keeps the parts apart, a jar of mắm here and a plate of herbs there, and lets the eater put them together.
Two more facts keep me from calling mắm a Central invention. Ishige Naomichi and Kenneth Ruddle surveyed fermented fish across Asia in the 1980s. They found that before the 20th century, mainland Southeast Asia fermented mostly freshwater fish, and Vietnamese nước mắm made from sea fish was the exception (Minpaku). The popular story that the Cham invented it rests on thin ground: one book cited by Wikipedia, plus museum lore about Roman traders. Rome had its own fish sauce, garum, and lost it after the empire fell. The word ketchup most likely comes from Hokkien kê-tsiap, a fish brine (NPR on Jurafsky). Rome, China and Vietnam all had fish sauce, and their spice habits went three different ways.
So mắm doesn't explain why Central cooks avoided spices. My best guess is that it explains why they never felt anything was missing. A kitchen with a year-old jar of anchovies, a garden of lemongrass and chili, and a table that finishes every dish already has the depth that a masala tin provides.
Where to Dig
- The cinnamon question. Why did a tribute-grade spice stay out of local cooking? Start with Okada's papers on the cinnamon trade to Japan (Osaka 2012; a 2020 Kyoto paper), then Lê Quý Đôn's Phủ biên tạp lục for Quảng Nam's local products. Whether spices passed through Hội An is still unconfirmed. Nguyễn Văn Kim's paper on Hội An's trade network is the entry point.
- Thực phổ bách thiên (1915). Trương Đăng Thị Bích wrote 102 poems on cooking for a princely household in Huế (Đại biểu Nhân dân). Read it to see whether the court spiced differently from ordinary homes. Nobody seems to have checked.
- Why tôm chua turns sour in a week. This needs a food-microbiology source on starch-assisted lactic fermentation in shrimp.
- Mắm nêm vs mắm cái. Fermentation time, whether the fish stays whole, and the names themselves all conflict between sources. A Hội An heritage text by Võ Hồng Việt may settle it.
- Củ nén's real species. Check POWO or Đỗ Tất Lợi's full entry, which lists it under A. ascalonicum.
- Fish sauce chemistry in full. The 2025 heating study at compound level, and a primary measurement of IMP in nước mắm, which so far is only a web statement.
- Salt reduction. Huynh et al. (J Food Sci, 2016) replaced 10–25% of the salt in broth, tomato sauce and curry with fish sauce without tasters noticing (Medical Xpress). Fish sauce is still about 1,400 mg sodium per tablespoon, so the real saving is smaller than it sounds.
- Hot and cold foods. The folk logic of nóng/lạnh, such as duck eaten with ginger, may explain some herb pairings. I haven't found a Vietnam-specific ethnography of it.
Author: Ope Tags: #culture Links: